Lights at St Joseph's Church

Home Photography Forums The Shark Tank Lights at St Joseph's Church

This topic contains 8 replies, has 9 voices, and was last updated by  Suheil unneen 5 years, 7 months ago.

  • Author
    Posts
  • #98648

    Donald Crais
    Participant

    St Joseph's Church NOLA by Donald Crais on Light Stalking

    St Joseph's Church in mid-town New Orleans. Between 150 – 200 years old. Lots of good light and old wood. Tried to shoot that day from a more intimate and different POV. On a tripod, no flash, approx. 2 sec exposure, f/16, ISO 100. Post-processed with nik.

  • #98687

    Walter Lustig
    Participant

    Could we see the high-res version, please?

    1. The lighting fixture is not exactly centred which I think in a shot like this it should be … I mean from left to right.

    2. The light areas of those windows(?) towards the top seem muddy and interfere with the warm light feeling you are trying to create/convey.

    3. In case you cropped on the bottom, I would leave 3-5mm more space but this is just sth I would try if possible.

    I think the out-of-centre and the muddiness bother me the most …

  • #98735

    caimi
    Participant

    Interesting perspective in that it may match that of every viewer of this fixture. It's asymmetric inclusion of the pillar at the left matches the seeming asymmetry of the windows above. There seems to be vignette added in post process which is a little heavy at the bottom but looks natural at the top.

  • #98747

    Tim Pinckard
    Participant

    In studying this shot, I feel that I am falling back and to the right. For me it is a little too much of a close upward shot. Sorry it just does not feel good to me.

  • #98869

    Mary Tuggle
    Participant

    I think the light fixture is centered, the asymmetry above gives the illusion of the fixture not being centered. I think I would crop just below the high windows. Would have to see it to know if it works.

  • #98886

    Ken Thomson
    Participant

    I've taken many photos of fixtures, wall sconces, paintings from this very angle – always wishing, “Gee, I wish I had a step ladder!” This seems to be one of those moments – if you have easy access to this Church, and they will let you, ask if you can carry in a small stepladder. I know the feeling of finding something so attractive, and wanting the shot even though you know it's not the best angle, so you shoot anyway. But to what end? There are nice textures in the wood, but a better angle and cropping.

  • #99191

    Ehpem
    Participant

    I like this shot, but I would try cropping it at or just above the brighter wood – lose the darker lattice and windows, that would keep my eye more on the fixture and less groping around up by the windows looking for something that is not there.

    It looks to me like part of the light (the circle where it joins the wall) is off-centre, and the higher parts are better centered. This is a bit disorienting, makes me want to twist my head. I think a touch of straightening on the vertical might fix that problem.

  • #99209

    Paul Gass
    Participant

    I like it but I also would crop off the top 1/5th of the picture, down to the wood. Also cut down the bright highlights of the photo to cut down on the light reflecting off the wood. Nice shot though.

  • #99213

    Suheil unneen
    Participant

    The uppermost portion of the image is distracting

You must be logged in to reply to this topic.