- September 19, 2018 at 11:38 pm #365749
Trying my hand with focus stacking using Arsenal. This is the first attempt. Eight stacked images shot with all natural light coming in from the right side of the image at about 7pm Eastern. Eight images 35mm, F7.1, 13 sec, ISO100. Stacked in PS edited with Luminar.
- This topic was modified 5 months ago by Jay Ward.
- September 20, 2018 at 12:11 am #365756
@jdublu Hi Jay, this is nicely done and I like the symmetry and light in the image.
It would have been better to see more of the top part and also, slightly brighten up the top left and right 🙂
- September 20, 2018 at 9:20 am #365913
Thanks Dahlia, I agree. The top is more than two stops lightened just to get what I have now. The natural light limitation really cast the organ pipes and cross into deep shadow.
- September 20, 2018 at 1:04 am #365772
Rob Wood (Admin)Keymaster
Seems pretty effective.
Focus stacking with Photoshop grinds my computer to a halt.
- September 20, 2018 at 9:22 am #365915
I partially cheated. I shot this as JPEGs instead of NEF to reduce the load on my laptop when I processed them.
- September 20, 2018 at 4:48 am #365820
Great Capture Jay, this image has a lot of potential. Nice job on focus stacking. There are a couple of things I would suggest for improvement…
Lighting: I like the way they natural light hits the pews; however, my eyes tend to stop there as the top of the image is dark … I would lighten up the Cross and curtain around it in the middle so that the viewers eyes start at the pews and follow directly up to the Cross.
Clone out distractions: microphone in middle, partial light in upper left corner, white streak upper left side, white spot upper right corner
- September 20, 2018 at 9:27 am #365920
Thanks Frogdaily, I agree with you. Unfortunately the cross and organ pipes were in deep shadow. I pushed it up two stops or so just to get what I have now. If I'd shot it in NEF I probably could have pulled a little more. I thought about removing the mics and lights but decided to leave well enough alone.
I used the nearest pew and the oil lamps on the alter as my two focus points. I find that the Arsenal doesn't cope well with extremely low light focusing. I could not get it to focus on the cross.
I'll try again with all of your suggestions. Thanks for the input.
- September 20, 2018 at 10:46 pm #366025
I like this shot Jay but it seems to have the main point of interest on the pews when all the interesting stuff is up back in the shadows so in this regard, I agree with Frogdaily's comments. Apart from that, I reckon a crop halfway between the bottom edge and the base of the altar, somewhere near that brightest line of light, just to enhance the symmetry even more might be worth checking out?
- September 21, 2018 at 3:00 pm #366179
Here's what I think you gracious folks suggested.
- September 21, 2018 at 1:27 am #366048
Wow, this is a really nice photograph, and perhaps the only valuable thing left here to say after all the feedback from other Light Stalkers for you mate is to take a look at Candida Höfer's work https://www.artsy.net/artist/candida-hofer
- September 21, 2018 at 9:46 pm #366219
Thanks for sharing the link Federico – Candida Höfer's images are amazing!
- September 21, 2018 at 9:42 pm #366217
Jay, I really like your newest edit – I agree with Dahlia that the lines caused by the shadows in the foreground in the original image are brilliant and with the final edit you brought them back – love that!
The composition on this is really nice – I like how you have now incorporated the layers of ceiling above the cross along with the beautiful lighting on the pews. The one thing I am missing is the lighting on the cross – to me this is the main subject and it is lost in the shadows.
Here are a few things I would do:
- Brighten up the cross – I used curve adjustments in selective areas to brighten the cross … I noticed there were a lot of red tones when I brightened the cross so I did a color balance on the midtones and highlights
- I also toned down the reds in the image using the Curve adjustment Red channel
- I burned the pleated areas in the curtain to bring some depth to them and bring a bit more detail.
- cloning out distractions: pamphlets in pew lower left corner, shiny pieces on the piano and toned down the shiny piece in middle behind the righthand red chair.
- The cross gets a little soft looking as you brighten it so I added a little clarity and dehazed
- I also dodged the lighting in the ceiling in the back to make it look like they are on
I see you allow editing so I thought I would show you what I am talking about to see if you like it. I used a screen capture so you will get better results with your original image.
- September 22, 2018 at 11:19 am #366254
Can I please just send all my images to you for final editing? I really like what you did. I had masked out the cross and worked with curves to bring it up but was losing detail. Thanks for the tip on how to fix.
This image was really just my first test with the Arsenal and the Cross was not the focal point, it was too dark to get Arsenal to use it as a focus point. You've vastly improved what I thought of as just an experimental test shot. Your comments and editing have improved my mediocre shot and increased my level of understanding about editing. Big Thanks!
- September 21, 2018 at 9:45 pm #366218
I also did a B&W version to see if you like it:
You must be logged in to reply to this topic.